Ingrid’s Fight to Be Seen Clearly

The Shape of Water

Ingrid is first made into a convenient scandal figure, then reveals the coercion and complicated loyalties behind the evidence against her.

increasing

Bearing strength in each event

decreasing

An Outsider in Montelusa An Outsider in Montelusa from "The Shape of Water". An Outsider in Montelusa A Distinct Presence Ingrid is a Swedish racing driver living within a powerful Sicilian family.

An Outsider in Montelusa from "The Shape of Water". An Outsider in Montelusa A Distinct Presence Ingrid is a Swedish racing driver living within a powerful Sicilian family.

An Outsider in Montelusa A Distinct Presence Ingrid is a Swedish racing driver living within a powerful Sicilian family. Her directness and independence make her easy to misread. Unequal Relations Her position in the household does not protect her from men who exert power over her.

The Coercive Relationship The Coercive Relationship from "The Shape of Water". The Coercive Relationship Repeated Harassment Dr Cardamone repeatedly approaches Ingrid and uses force and intimidation.

The Coercive Relationship from "The Shape of Water". The Coercive Relationship Repeated Harassment Dr Cardamone repeatedly approaches Ingrid and uses force and intimidation.

The Coercive Relationship Repeated Harassment Dr Cardamone repeatedly approaches Ingrid and uses force and intimidation. She asks her husband to move away, but he refuses. A Private Refuge She seeks occasional shelter in Luparello’s cottage, complicating the later interpretation of her clothes there.

A Convenient Accusation A Convenient Accusation from "The Shape of Water". A Convenient Accusation Evidence Against Her Her bag, necklace, and spare clothes are arranged to connect her with the dead politician and the Pasture.

A Convenient Accusation from "The Shape of Water". A Convenient Accusation Evidence Against Her Her bag, necklace, and spare clothes are arranged to connect her with the dead politician and the Pasture.

A Convenient Accusation Evidence Against Her Her bag, necklace, and spare clothes are arranged to connect her with the dead politician and the Pasture. Isolation The false story exploits her reputation and foreignness, making her a plausible target for gossip.

Truth in the Cottage Truth in the Cottage from "The Shape of Water". Truth in the Cottage Her Account Ingrid admits she once slept with Luparello but says their relationship became a friendship.

Truth in the Cottage from "The Shape of Water". Truth in the Cottage Her Account Ingrid admits she once slept with Luparello but says their relationship became a friendship.

Truth in the Cottage Her Account Ingrid admits she once slept with Luparello but says their relationship became a friendship. She had used the cottage to escape her father-in-law’s advances. Complicated Loyalty She does not know how far her husband has been drawn into the framing plan.

A Narrow Escape A Narrow Escape from "The Shape of Water". A Narrow Escape Evidence Removed Montalbano destroys the physical trail that could be used against her.

A Narrow Escape from "The Shape of Water". A Narrow Escape Evidence Removed Montalbano destroys the physical trail that could be used against her.

A Narrow Escape Evidence Removed Montalbano destroys the physical trail that could be used against her. Ingrid accepts his help but leaves without resolving her marriage. Protection Without Justice She escapes the immediate frame, while the powerful relationships that endangered her remain largely intact.

The years before the case

The years before Luparello’s death

After Luparello’s death

The night Montalbano takes her to Capo Massaria

Late that night